Skip to content

FREE SHIPPING ON ALL ORDERS IN CANADA OVER $175

FREE SHIPPING ON ALL ORDERS IN CANADA OVER $175

Proudly serving the Big & Tall Man since 1925

Currency

CAD $
USD $

M.H. Grover & Sons

FR

Search Account 0 Cart

Suits
- Sport Jackets
- Suits
Shirts
Polos & Tees
- Polo Shirts
- T-Shirts
Pants
Athletic Wear
Outerwear
Sleep & Underwear
Accessories
Brands
Liquidation

Goes great with

100% Leather Belt

from $78⁰⁰ from $78.00

100% Leather Belt

$98⁰⁰ $98.00

462 Stealth Black 463 Charcoal Grey 464 Azul Blue

2UNDR Sport Shift Boxer Brief

$35⁰⁰ $35.00

001 g/bl 002 bk/g 007 b/bl 006 Red +3

2UNDR Swing Shift Boxer Brief

$35⁰⁰ $35.00

Add order note Close

Subtotal

$0.00

Shipping, taxes, and discount codes calculated at checkout.

Your cart is currently empty.

Brands
Liquidation

Home / Collections / Accessories /

Johnston & Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe

SKU: 25-2980

Johnston & Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe

Johnston & Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe

<img class="lazyloaded" src="//groversbigandtall.com/cdn/shop/files/252980_master_1_800x.jpg?v=1749661236" alt="Johnston & Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe">

Johnston & Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe

<img class="lazyloaded" src="//groversbigandtall.com/cdn/shop/files/252980_master_2_800x.jpg?v=1749661242" alt="Johnston & Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe">

Johnston & Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe

<img class="lazyloaded" src="//groversbigandtall.com/cdn/shop/files/252980_master_3_800x.jpg?v=1749661247" alt="Johnston & Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe">

Johnston & Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe

Johnston & Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe

Johnston & Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe

Johnston & Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe

Home / Collections / Accessories /

Johnston & Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe

SKU: 25-2980

Size

Size

9 Wide

9.5 Wide

10 Wide

10.5 Wide

11 Wide

11.5 Wide

12 Wide

13

14

15

16

Color — Brown Oil Full Grain

Color

Brown Oil Full Grain

Price Regular price$199⁹⁵ $199.95

/

Shipping calculated at checkout.

Quantity

[{"id":46541120504044,"title":"9 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","option1":"9 Wide","option2":"Brown Oil Full Grain","option3":null,"sku":"25-2980","requires_shipping":true,"taxable":true,"featured_image":{"id":43611880915180,"product_id":8942198620396,"position":1,"created_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:28-04:00","updated_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:29-04:00","alt":null,"width":2000,"height":1884,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229","variant_ids":[46541117915372,46541117948140,46541117980908,46541118013676,46541120504044,46541120536812,46541120569580,46541120602348,46541120635116,46541120667884,46541121814764]},"available":true,"name":"Johnston \u0026 Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe - 9 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","public_title":"9 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","options":["9 Wide","Brown Oil Full Grain"],"price":19995,"weight":0,"compare_at_price":19995,"inventory_management":null,"barcode":"","featured_media":{"alt":null,"id":35520223412460,"position":1,"preview_image":{"aspect_ratio":1.062,"height":1884,"width":2000,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229"}},"requires_selling_plan":false,"selling_plan_allocations":[]},{"id":46541120536812,"title":"9.5 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","option1":"9.5 Wide","option2":"Brown Oil Full Grain","option3":null,"sku":"25-2980","requires_shipping":true,"taxable":true,"featured_image":{"id":43611880915180,"product_id":8942198620396,"position":1,"created_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:28-04:00","updated_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:29-04:00","alt":null,"width":2000,"height":1884,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229","variant_ids":[46541117915372,46541117948140,46541117980908,46541118013676,46541120504044,46541120536812,46541120569580,46541120602348,46541120635116,46541120667884,46541121814764]},"available":true,"name":"Johnston \u0026 Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe - 9.5 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","public_title":"9.5 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","options":["9.5 Wide","Brown Oil Full Grain"],"price":19995,"weight":0,"compare_at_price":19995,"inventory_management":null,"barcode":"","featured_media":{"alt":null,"id":35520223412460,"position":1,"preview_image":{"aspect_ratio":1.062,"height":1884,"width":2000,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229"}},"requires_selling_plan":false,"selling_plan_allocations":[]},{"id":46541117915372,"title":"10 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","option1":"10 Wide","option2":"Brown Oil Full Grain","option3":null,"sku":"25-2980","requires_shipping":true,"taxable":true,"featured_image":{"id":43611880915180,"product_id":8942198620396,"position":1,"created_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:28-04:00","updated_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:29-04:00","alt":null,"width":2000,"height":1884,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229","variant_ids":[46541117915372,46541117948140,46541117980908,46541118013676,46541120504044,46541120536812,46541120569580,46541120602348,46541120635116,46541120667884,46541121814764]},"available":true,"name":"Johnston \u0026 Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe - 10 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","public_title":"10 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","options":["10 Wide","Brown Oil Full Grain"],"price":19995,"weight":0,"compare_at_price":19995,"inventory_management":null,"barcode":null,"featured_media":{"alt":null,"id":35520223412460,"position":1,"preview_image":{"aspect_ratio":1.062,"height":1884,"width":2000,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229"}},"requires_selling_plan":false,"selling_plan_allocations":[]},{"id":46541117948140,"title":"10.5 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","option1":"10.5 Wide","option2":"Brown Oil Full Grain","option3":null,"sku":"25-2980","requires_shipping":true,"taxable":true,"featured_image":{"id":43611880915180,"product_id":8942198620396,"position":1,"created_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:28-04:00","updated_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:29-04:00","alt":null,"width":2000,"height":1884,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229","variant_ids":[46541117915372,46541117948140,46541117980908,46541118013676,46541120504044,46541120536812,46541120569580,46541120602348,46541120635116,46541120667884,46541121814764]},"available":true,"name":"Johnston \u0026 Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe - 10.5 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","public_title":"10.5 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","options":["10.5 Wide","Brown Oil Full Grain"],"price":19995,"weight":0,"compare_at_price":19995,"inventory_management":null,"barcode":null,"featured_media":{"alt":null,"id":35520223412460,"position":1,"preview_image":{"aspect_ratio":1.062,"height":1884,"width":2000,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229"}},"requires_selling_plan":false,"selling_plan_allocations":[]},{"id":46541117980908,"title":"11 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","option1":"11 Wide","option2":"Brown Oil Full Grain","option3":null,"sku":"25-2980","requires_shipping":true,"taxable":true,"featured_image":{"id":43611880915180,"product_id":8942198620396,"position":1,"created_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:28-04:00","updated_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:29-04:00","alt":null,"width":2000,"height":1884,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229","variant_ids":[46541117915372,46541117948140,46541117980908,46541118013676,46541120504044,46541120536812,46541120569580,46541120602348,46541120635116,46541120667884,46541121814764]},"available":true,"name":"Johnston \u0026 Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe - 11 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","public_title":"11 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","options":["11 Wide","Brown Oil Full Grain"],"price":19995,"weight":0,"compare_at_price":19995,"inventory_management":null,"barcode":null,"featured_media":{"alt":null,"id":35520223412460,"position":1,"preview_image":{"aspect_ratio":1.062,"height":1884,"width":2000,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229"}},"requires_selling_plan":false,"selling_plan_allocations":[]},{"id":46541120569580,"title":"11.5 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","option1":"11.5 Wide","option2":"Brown Oil Full Grain","option3":null,"sku":"25-2980","requires_shipping":true,"taxable":true,"featured_image":{"id":43611880915180,"product_id":8942198620396,"position":1,"created_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:28-04:00","updated_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:29-04:00","alt":null,"width":2000,"height":1884,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229","variant_ids":[46541117915372,46541117948140,46541117980908,46541118013676,46541120504044,46541120536812,46541120569580,46541120602348,46541120635116,46541120667884,46541121814764]},"available":true,"name":"Johnston \u0026 Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe - 11.5 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","public_title":"11.5 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","options":["11.5 Wide","Brown Oil Full Grain"],"price":19995,"weight":0,"compare_at_price":19995,"inventory_management":null,"barcode":"","featured_media":{"alt":null,"id":35520223412460,"position":1,"preview_image":{"aspect_ratio":1.062,"height":1884,"width":2000,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229"}},"requires_selling_plan":false,"selling_plan_allocations":[]},{"id":46541118013676,"title":"12 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","option1":"12 Wide","option2":"Brown Oil Full Grain","option3":null,"sku":"25-2980","requires_shipping":true,"taxable":true,"featured_image":{"id":43611880915180,"product_id":8942198620396,"position":1,"created_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:28-04:00","updated_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:29-04:00","alt":null,"width":2000,"height":1884,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229","variant_ids":[46541117915372,46541117948140,46541117980908,46541118013676,46541120504044,46541120536812,46541120569580,46541120602348,46541120635116,46541120667884,46541121814764]},"available":true,"name":"Johnston \u0026 Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe - 12 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","public_title":"12 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","options":["12 Wide","Brown Oil Full Grain"],"price":19995,"weight":0,"compare_at_price":19995,"inventory_management":null,"barcode":null,"featured_media":{"alt":null,"id":35520223412460,"position":1,"preview_image":{"aspect_ratio":1.062,"height":1884,"width":2000,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229"}},"requires_selling_plan":false,"selling_plan_allocations":[]},{"id":46541120602348,"title":"13 \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","option1":"13","option2":"Brown Oil Full Grain","option3":null,"sku":"25-2980","requires_shipping":true,"taxable":true,"featured_image":{"id":43611880915180,"product_id":8942198620396,"position":1,"created_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:28-04:00","updated_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:29-04:00","alt":null,"width":2000,"height":1884,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229","variant_ids":[46541117915372,46541117948140,46541117980908,46541118013676,46541120504044,46541120536812,46541120569580,46541120602348,46541120635116,46541120667884,46541121814764]},"available":true,"name":"Johnston \u0026 Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe - 13 \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","public_title":"13 \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","options":["13","Brown Oil Full Grain"],"price":19995,"weight":0,"compare_at_price":19995,"inventory_management":null,"barcode":"","featured_media":{"alt":null,"id":35520223412460,"position":1,"preview_image":{"aspect_ratio":1.062,"height":1884,"width":2000,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229"}},"requires_selling_plan":false,"selling_plan_allocations":[]},{"id":46541120635116,"title":"14 \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","option1":"14","option2":"Brown Oil Full Grain","option3":null,"sku":"25-2980","requires_shipping":true,"taxable":true,"featured_image":{"id":43611880915180,"product_id":8942198620396,"position":1,"created_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:28-04:00","updated_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:29-04:00","alt":null,"width":2000,"height":1884,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229","variant_ids":[46541117915372,46541117948140,46541117980908,46541118013676,46541120504044,46541120536812,46541120569580,46541120602348,46541120635116,46541120667884,46541121814764]},"available":true,"name":"Johnston \u0026 Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe - 14 \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","public_title":"14 \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","options":["14","Brown Oil Full Grain"],"price":19995,"weight":0,"compare_at_price":19995,"inventory_management":null,"barcode":"","featured_media":{"alt":null,"id":35520223412460,"position":1,"preview_image":{"aspect_ratio":1.062,"height":1884,"width":2000,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229"}},"requires_selling_plan":false,"selling_plan_allocations":[]},{"id":46541120667884,"title":"15 \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","option1":"15","option2":"Brown Oil Full Grain","option3":null,"sku":"25-2980","requires_shipping":true,"taxable":true,"featured_image":{"id":43611880915180,"product_id":8942198620396,"position":1,"created_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:28-04:00","updated_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:29-04:00","alt":null,"width":2000,"height":1884,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229","variant_ids":[46541117915372,46541117948140,46541117980908,46541118013676,46541120504044,46541120536812,46541120569580,46541120602348,46541120635116,46541120667884,46541121814764]},"available":true,"name":"Johnston \u0026 Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe - 15 \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","public_title":"15 \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","options":["15","Brown Oil Full Grain"],"price":19995,"weight":0,"compare_at_price":19995,"inventory_management":null,"barcode":"","featured_media":{"alt":null,"id":35520223412460,"position":1,"preview_image":{"aspect_ratio":1.062,"height":1884,"width":2000,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229"}},"requires_selling_plan":false,"selling_plan_allocations":[]},{"id":46541121814764,"title":"16 \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","option1":"16","option2":"Brown Oil Full Grain","option3":null,"sku":"25-2980","requires_shipping":true,"taxable":true,"featured_image":{"id":43611880915180,"product_id":8942198620396,"position":1,"created_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:28-04:00","updated_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:29-04:00","alt":null,"width":2000,"height":1884,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229","variant_ids":[46541117915372,46541117948140,46541117980908,46541118013676,46541120504044,46541120536812,46541120569580,46541120602348,46541120635116,46541120667884,46541121814764]},"available":true,"name":"Johnston \u0026 Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe - 16 \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","public_title":"16 \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","options":["16","Brown Oil Full Grain"],"price":19995,"weight":0,"compare_at_price":19995,"inventory_management":null,"barcode":"","featured_media":{"alt":null,"id":35520223412460,"position":1,"preview_image":{"aspect_ratio":1.062,"height":1884,"width":2000,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229"}},"requires_selling_plan":false,"selling_plan_allocations":[]}]

{"id":46541120504044,"title":"9 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","option1":"9 Wide","option2":"Brown Oil Full Grain","option3":null,"sku":"25-2980","requires_shipping":true,"taxable":true,"featured_image":{"id":43611880915180,"product_id":8942198620396,"position":1,"created_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:28-04:00","updated_at":"2025-06-11T13:00:29-04:00","alt":null,"width":2000,"height":1884,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229","variant_ids":[46541117915372,46541117948140,46541117980908,46541118013676,46541120504044,46541120536812,46541120569580,46541120602348,46541120635116,46541120667884,46541121814764]},"available":true,"name":"Johnston \u0026 Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe - 9 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","public_title":"9 Wide \/ Brown Oil Full Grain","options":["9 Wide","Brown Oil Full Grain"],"price":19995,"weight":0,"compare_at_price":19995,"inventory_management":null,"barcode":"","featured_media":{"alt":null,"id":35520223412460,"position":1,"preview_image":{"aspect_ratio":1.062,"height":1884,"width":2000,"src":"\/\/groversbigandtall.com\/cdn\/shop\/files\/252980_master.jpg?v=1749661229"}},"requires_selling_plan":false,"selling_plan_allocations":[]}

Our beloved McGuffey style with subtle updates for a more modern silhouette and enhanced comfort.
Supple full-grain leather upper.
Even more comfortable with our XC Foam® midsole for superb rebound and durability.
Padded tongue, heel, and collar.
Subtly contrasting topstitching and piping on select colors.
Latex and EVA wedge footbed with cushioned arch support and textile covering.
Leather and textile lining.
Slightly thicker rubber sole.

Name

Email

Phone number Message

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

You may also like

Brown Oil Full Grain

Johnston & Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe

$199⁹⁵ $199.95

More from Johnston & Murphy

Brown Oil Full Grain

Johnston & Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe

$199⁹⁵ $199.95

More from Accessories

Black Navy Grey

Custom Leather Stretch Cotton Woven Belt

$50⁰⁰ $50.00

Johnston & Murphy Gibbons Cap Toe

$210⁰⁰ $210.00

Johnston & Murphy Upton Dress Plain Toe

$210⁰⁰ $210.00

Tan Oil Full Grain

Johnston & Murphy Upton Plain Toe

$210⁰⁰ $210.00

Brown Oil Full Grain

Johnston & Murphy McGuffey 2 Plain Toe

$199⁹⁵ $199.95

Zelikovitz Leather Belt

$60⁰⁰ $60.00

Recently viewed

Back to Accessories

Join our mailing list & save!

Enter your email

Our Company

About Us
Contact Us
Merchandise Alterations
Shipping & Returns
Terms & Conditions
Privacy Policy

Get in touch

(514) 769 3771
Email us

Follow us

Instagram
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest

We accept

Language

English
français

Currency

CAD $
USD $

© 2025 M.H. Grover & Sons

Join our mailing list & save!

Be the first to know about our sales, coupons and promotions!

Enter your email

English

French
English

Cookie preferences

Accept all

Decline all

Save my preferences

Accept all

Decline all

Save my preferences

You control your data

You can control how your data is used on our website. Learn more about the cookies we use and choose which cookies work for you.

If you accept all cookies

Our site may be improved based on your interests
Your preferences may be stored for when your return
You may see advertising that’s tailored to you

Operate the website

These cookies are required for the site to function and for necessary activities like protecting against fraud.

Measure performance

These cookies help to understand how you interact with the site and what types of content are valuable to you.

Store you preferences

These cookies help remember your preferences, like your country or language, to personalize your next visits to the website.

Personalize marketing

These cookies are used to provide ads on other sites and marketing communications based on your interests.

We value your privacy

We and our partners use cookies and other technologies to improve your experience, measure performance, and tailor marketing. Details in our Privacy Policy

Manage preferences

Decline

Accept